Monday, February 18, 2008

Improving Our Arizona Forests

FUNERAL ANNOUNCEMENT
"Dearly beloved…we are gathered here today to remember another lost friend belonging to the brotherhood of Arizona mountain retreats….Mount Lemmon….The Chiricahuas…..Mount Graham…..Mount Wrightson…..Carr Peak…..Mogollon Rim.....Kendrick Mountain.....Mt. Elden.....Mazatzal Peak......Four Peaks......

We are saddened by the loss that has been needlessly thrust upon us again. These mountains have suffered for years from neglect and fire suppresion and had recently been diagnosed with terminal "threat-of-fire disease." We will miss them dearly.
Bravo to the powers that be for allowing the once beautiful southern Arizona mountain ranges to degenerate into ash heaps and scrub brush one by one.
I suppose one could blame the USFS but they simply inherited the proverbial, "500 pound gorilla" called "Excessive Fuel Load" and have been left to just try to keep it caged. Now it has gotten out and has done so repeatedly.

The Chiricahuas in 1994,
Mt. Lemmon in 2003,
Mt. Graham in 2004
Mt. Wrightson in 2005.
Rodeo-Chedeski in 2002
Dude fire of 1990
Carr Canyon 1977
The Radio Burn 1977.
Many were in wilderness areas, and Mt. Graham was (is?) a wilderness study area (WSA). Some were lit by lightning, but many were man-caused. Though those that were not might just as well have been. For those kinds of blazes were inevitable.

Now to those who think that these fires were "natural" and a "good" thing, think again. While they did relieve the fuel loads where they burned, they will recur if the past habit of fire suppression continues. For the brush that will replace much of the forests will be as flammable as ever. There also is simply too much to replant with trees. I lived in southern Arizona for most of my life and enjoyed these areas. I was thrilled when some were made wilderness. It meant that no one could go up and mine and log. However it kept out the ability to restore the areas to "wilderness." A line on a map and a label in a government office does not a wilderness make, I have learned. There needed to be a transition time to make the areas ready for wilderness status. Even if it meant, for example, doing thinning in the Chiricahuas or even on Wrightson (perish the thought) for a time, then removing the trails and drag lines. Wouldn’t that have been better that what is there now? (Black tree trunks…) And remember....many areas already had roads and access.
Sure, the forests will return…… in 100 to 300 years. However, it did not need to be. Thinning, clearing, and other things could have been done over years with volunteer help without roads if the environmentalists would have kept out of it. (sorry, but it’s true..) The local foresters knew best what to do, but, no, no, no, it is "wilderness," so just let nature "take its course" and keep out those nasty chain saws (even the fire fighters on the Florida Fire had to "follow the rules" by not using excessive motorized equipment like chain saws, at least in the beginning, though it is doubtful it would have made any difference. Though IF they had gotten on it RIGHT AWAY with all means possible……..)
A forest with those kind of EFL’s (see "gorilla" above) is NOT WILD and should NEVER have been treated as such.
So....Enough complaining....
So what to do???

#1. Conduct burns in critical overgrown areas ASAP when the weather cools and gets damp EACH YEAR. Burn high and let them creep downhill. If there is some crowning, so be it. But it will be minimal compared to what we have seen in JUST 7 years!!!! Pile and burn slash and dead wood in winter.

#2. Let local forest supervisors manage their districts without beauracratic red tape….(Ha, Ha, Ha, Ha, Ha…..just a joke)

#3. Allow anyone to haul dead wood for FREE inside forest lands including wildernesses. Pay private firewood suppliers per truckload to remove dead and down on Mt. Graham.

#4. All forested areas need to burn at least once every ten years. (more or less) Everyone who knows something about western forest knows this (see #1).

#5. Work to save forests, not structures in the contact zones when there is a fire. I know this is a radical idea and many will say, "Well, would you want YOUR house being burned?" I will say this. If I lived on Mount Lemmon in the woods and had a house or cabin there and had a choice of losing it OR having the mountain burn like it did, I would give up the house. Ask the residents there if they COULD have had a choice, what they would have chosen. See what they say. You can rebuild a house but you can’t replace a 300 year old grove of trees.

#6. Change the way fires are fought. The "dog and pony show" of slurry tankers and pulaskis working fire lines will NOT do the job* (with ALL due respect to the guys that fly and build the lines who are just following orders given by fire bosses who are not allowed to do what needs to be done, or are just following half-century old fire wisdom used in damper climates-----Hello, we live in a dry area!!!!).
*Look...has it done the job?

#7. Use whatever is necessary, to contain fires quickly. Fires MUST NOT be allowed to enter areas that will burn catastrophically until they can be pretreated. Either get SERIOUS about controlling fires until areas can be made safer for fires or let them burn, get everyone out of the way, and save the money. The Aspen Fire and The Florida Fire burned where they wished with out regard to the millions spent to "control them." (If you consider building a swath in the desert miles from the forest a legitimate containment line. I do not.)

Years ago I hiked Florida Canyon and saw its green beauty. It is an absolute shame to allow it to be destroyed. No one will see it as it was before the year 2200. As a young person, I recognized the potential for a fire there. Our user fees should go primarily to help prevent these kinds of fires, not just building new toilets and paying rangers to haul garbage. Bravo, to the Fed….They spent $8 million to "fight" the fire??? Well, the fire won……What---tell me WHAT was accomplished? The fire did what it wanted to. The USFS has done NOTHING to help manage fuel loads or reduce fire risk for decades in the southern Arizona mountains. They risked pilots to try and save the unsavable. Now we know, of course that not all of Madera Canyon or Mount Lemmon is ruined. From what I have seen on the web heard about from the fire fighters themselves, they put up a valiant effort in places, but rain finally did the work….And why were they busy building fire line in the desert by Box Canyon???? To keep the fire from destroying irreplaceable grass and prickly pear, I know. (Pressure from the UA perhaps??) And why all the effort to save telescopes? (Why didn't they do their "make defensible space" work AHEAD OF TIME?) I think that the people need to know that the "Horse is out of the barn" and all that can be done now is to try and save the fragmented sickly forest that is left on our mountains. The Dept of Agriculture had dropped the ball on forest management.
I know this is a sort of rant against a beaurocracy that is so cumbersome that it cannot do what needs to be done. I just want the obvious blunders made known and admitted to by those in charge. Why can't they ask for help? Help us to trust them again.

No comments: